
Pennsylvania's Failed System of Indigent Defense


Both the U.S. and Pennsylvania constitutions guarantee the right to an attorney for someone facing criminal charges, regardless of a person’s ability to pay. But for decades, Pennsylvania has been woefully inadequate in ensuring that people living in poverty receive effective representation.
So in June, the ACLU of Pennsylvania, with volunteer attorneys from several law firms, sued the governor and the leaders of the General Assembly because the executive and legislative branches have failed their constitutional duties.
In this episode, we hear from Veronica Miller, senior policy counsel for criminal legal reform, and Ari Shapell, fellowship attorney, both at the ACLU of PA. Veronica and Ari are co-counsel in the case, Warren v. Commonwealth. In this conversation, they explain how Pennsylvania’s indigent defense system has failed and what we hope to achieve with this litigation.
Related content


What Pennsylvania’s failure to fund public defenders means across...
September 19, 2024
HB 956 | Automatic felony enhancement for simple assault against...
May 12, 2025
HB 1042 | PA Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act
April 30, 2025
HB 282 | Providing medical assistance upon reentry
April 30, 2025
ACLU of Pa. Calls for Increased Funding for Pennsylvania’s Public...
March 26, 2025
SB 347 | Criminalizing overdose prevention sites
March 21, 2025
SB 92 | Mandatory minimum for drug delivery (Tyler's Law)
March 21, 2025